Active Noise Control for Wind Turbines

1. Blade-Scale Aerodynamic Adaptation and Operating-Point Perturbation

Utility-scale machines radiate most of their acoustic energy from the outer one-third of the blade, where local inflow turbulence, boundary-layer transition, and tip vortices interact with large chord lengths and high relative velocities. Historically that noise has been mitigated with passive serrations or blanket curtailment, neither of which discriminates between the genuinely noisy span-wise sectors and the comparatively quiet ones. Recent advances instead treat the rotor as a controllable acoustic radiator whose surface, pitch, and speed can be perturbed in real time to break the physical mechanisms that launch the loudest pressure waves.

1.1 Event-Driven Surface Actuation

The event-driven blade-surface actuation concept places piezo-powered micro-tabs, inflatable gurneys, or adaptive trailing-edge flaps along each blade section. A blade internal bus collects microphone, pressure-tap, and tip-clearance data at kilohertz rates and streams it to a Noise Manager embedded in the turbine safety PLC. Whenever the spectral power in any monitored band drifts beyond a threshold tied to the site’s regulatory limit, the controller commands a localised deflection rather than a wholesale pitch slowdown. That precisely timed deflection alters boundary-layer instability growth so that the imminent vortex shedding cycle weakens before it can radiate. Field demonstrations on 3 MW platforms show that a five-degree flap deployment confined to 15 percent of the span can trim trailing-edge noise by 4 dB(A) while sacrificing less than 0.3 percent power for a 10-minute compliance window. Because the flap is re-stowed once the transient passes, annual energy production (AEP) remains virtually unchanged.

1.2 Azimuth-Resolved Model Predictive Control

Where the previous scheme manipulates hardware, the azimuth-resolved noise model predictive control approach keeps the mechanics intact and lets software do the heavy lifting. A reduced-order aeroelastic model tracks angle of attack, inflow shear, and span-wise loading for every blade slice at one-degree azimuth resolution. By predicting noise directivity for the upcoming rotor revolution, the MPC computes individual-pitch and generator-torque commands that maintain a target noise budget on a per-blade, per-azimuth basis. The algorithm corrects for the fact that each blade passes through shear, tower shadow, and free-inflow sectors once per turn, creating blade-to-blade level variations that traditional collective-pitch loops ignore. The real-time controller runs on the nacelle’s existing DSP, updating every 100 ms, so the economics are attractive for large fleets. Trials on an aligned four-turbine row reduced amplitude modulation depth at a 600 m receptor by 2 dB without any operator-perceived loss in energy capture.

1.3 Set-Point Perturbation to Suppress Tonal Resonance

Broadband noise limits often mask the presence of pure tones, but once broadband levels drop, turbine resonances around tower or blade natural frequencies become highly audible. The set-point perturbation for tonal noise suppression strategy attacks the root cause by superimposing a micro-dither on the optimal rotor-speed or pitch reference. The dither follows a pre-computed multisine whose amplitude envelope respects blade and drivetrain fatigue limits stored in a look-up table. Because the machine never dwells long enough at the resonant RPM, structural amplification does not build up, and the resulting acoustic energy is smeared over several narrow bands, each below the threshold of audibility. A 2 Hz peak-to-peak speed variation applied to a 4 MW direct-drive unit reduced the 1P tonal signature by 6 dB while shaving only 0.4 percent from instantaneous power.

By combining physical surface adaptation, azimuth-aware predictive control, and micro-set-point dithering, operators can select the gentlest, least costly mitigation tier for any operating hour, and upgrade legacy fleets using only the elements that local regulations require.

---

2. Blade-Integrated Sensor-Actuator Arrays for Trailing-Edge and Tip Noise Cancellation

Even with smart pitch and surface control, the turbulent boundary layer at high Reynolds numbers radiates broadband sound above 500 Hz, which propagates poorly but remains locally annoying. Directly cancelling that pressure field before it detaches from the blade sidesteps the need for curtailment. Two technology strands are now mature enough for on-blade deployment.

2.1 Logarithmically Spaced Pressure-Noise Arrays

The non-uniformly spaced microphone-loudspeaker array lays three or more MEMS microphones in a geometric progression along the chord. The spacing eliminates spatial aliasing, allowing an adaptive finite-impulse-response (FIR) filter to identify the convecting turbulent eddies responsible for the loudest scattered sound. Downstream flush-mounted electrodynamic actuators inject an equal amplitude, opposite phase pressure field with a 0.3 ms latency, well within the convection time across the local panel. Wind-tunnel measurements on a 1.5 m chord demonstrated 8 dB cancellation at 2 kHz with no measurable lift-to-drag penalty. A distributed power bus draws less than 50 W per blade section, making the approach viable for multi-megawatt machines.

2.2 Hybrid Passive-Active Serration Modules

Sawtooth serrations are standard OEM accessories but only deliver 1 to 2 dB reduction above 1 kHz. The serration-conformal sensing–actuation module bonds a flexible Kapton circuit into the serration substrate. Pressure sensors sample the unsteady Reynolds stresses, while piezo discs glued to the inner surface inject counter-phase vibrations that scramble the coherence length of turbulent structures. Laboratory rigs on 900 mm glass-fiber panels showed that combining a 30 mm-deep serration with the active layer achieved 5–6 dB broadband suppression over 1–4 kHz, triple the passive-only figure. The flexible module can be co-cured into new blades or adhesively bonded during a scheduled leading-edge repair, aligning well with service downtimes.

2.3 Design Integration Considerations

Both architectures must withstand cyclic root bending of up to ±300 MPa and surface erosion by rain droplet impact at 90 m s⁻¹. Embedding the wiring harness inside the trailing-edge shear web and potting the connectors with silicone gel currently offers a five-year qualification under IEC 61400-24 lightning test protocol. Control loops remain feed-forward to avoid the phase uncertainty introduced by rotating reference microphones, although recent work on rotor-based beamforming promises to close a feedback loop in the future.

---

3. Structure-Borne Noise from Gearboxes, Generators, and Support Structures

Inside the nacelle, mechanical sources dominate below 500 Hz. Those frequencies propagate along the tower shell with limited atmospheric attenuation, often driving complaints at distances where aerodynamic noise has already decayed. Active solutions therefore target the vibration source or the radiation path before trying any far-field acoustic manipulation.

3.1 Multi-Sensor Active Mufflers for Geartrain Modules

The multi-sensor active muffler architecture wraps the high-speed and intermediate shafts with a composite shell that is acoustically transparent at the intake but houses six distributed magnet-coil shakers and eight boundary microphones on the inner wall. Accelerometers mounted on the gearbox bearings deliver a predictive reference so the FIR controller can drive destructive anti-noise through the shell skin. The compact enclosure replaces heavy mineral-wool blankets without impeding airflow. A 4 MW prototype achieved 12 dB attenuation at the gearmesh 160 Hz fundamental and 5–7 dB at the first two harmonics, allowing the OEM to delete 400 kg of insulation and enlarge the cooling louvers.

3.2 Fractional-Harmonic Compensation in Direct-Drive Generators

For turbines that eliminate gearboxes, fractional slot concentrated-winding generators introduce torque ripple at frequencies that are not integer multiples of electrical frequency. The fractional-harmonic current cancellation algorithm blends the coarse 24-bit resolver angle with the inverter’s 18 kHz PWM carrier phase to form a hybrid timing base. A narrowband inverse filter injects a compensating stator current component to flatten torque within ±0.5 percent. On a 107-m rotor, acoustic measurements inside the tower base showed an 8 dB cut at the 2.3 Hz infrasonic component traditionally associated with occupant fatigue and sleep disturbance. Because RMS current rises by less than 0.8 percent, generator copper loss increase is negligible.

3.3 Tower and Foundation Damping Augmentation

Once vibration reaches the tower shell, mitigations get costlier. Tuned mass dampers deliver only single-mode relief, and viscoelastic layers add tonnes of weight. A new hybrid uses six voice-coil shakers at one-third tower height controlled by an H-infinity algorithm that references nacelle accelerometers. The shakers require less than 2 kW during a 12 m s⁻¹ wind event yet suppress the first flexural mode by 4 dB at the foundation, which translates to 2 dB at a 1 km dwelling. This technique pairs naturally with the gearbox and generator cancellation layers so that each stage delivers incremental reductions before the acoustic wave leaves the structure.

---

4. Distributed Secondary Acoustic Sources on Rotor, Nacelle, and Perimeter

Cancelling noise where it is generated is efficient but not always feasible, for example during high-shear night-time conditions when low-frequency propagation is strongest. Embedding secondary sources along the acoustic path lets operators shape the far-field radiation without altering blade aerodynamics.

4.1 Rotor-Integrated Loudspeaker Patches

The blade-mounted secondary sound sources keep the acoustic radiator on the blade but decouple it from direct fluid-structure interaction. Flat 3 mm-thick electret panels bonded 30 percent aft of the leading edge broadcast cancellation signals derived from onboard pressure sensors. Output above 400 Hz is attenuated by the composite laminate, so mid-bass energy is targeted instead. Field tests on a 2 MW turbine measured 5 dB reduction at 250 Hz in the maximum directivity lobe without a measurable drag rise.

4.2 Intra-Blade Loudspeaker-Microphone Pairs

Lower frequency coverage requires larger diaphragms. The embedded intra-blade loudspeaker–microphone pair mounts an 80 mm driver against the inner spar, firing outward through a tuned Helmholtz cavity in the shell laminate. Microphones on the outer skin close a feedback loop that enforces a zero-pressure boundary at the blade surface. The scheme attenuates up to 5 dB at 100 Hz but raises blade mass by 12 kg. OEM studies indicate that the extra mass offsets only 0.01 percent AEP on a 5 MW machine.

4.3 Perimeter and Tower-Based Source Arrays

If site topography concentrates receptors in a particular sector, external arrays become attractive. The yaw-adaptive inverse-filter array mounts twenty 12-inch woofers on a ring 5 m outside the rotor sweep, aligned with the tower’s yaw bearing. Array weights change whenever nacelle azimuth shifts, preserving destructive interference toward static monitoring masts. Cancellation of 20–200 Hz content is maintained within ±2 dB for yaw angles spanning 120°. Where real estate is limited, tower-mounted horn drivers driven by the geo-referenced adaptive ANC algorithm emit directional counter-noise toward only the protected azimuth, conserving electrical power and loudspeaker life.

4.4 Conditional, Multi-Stage ANC Curtains

Multi-row sites occasionally need broadband mitigation when atmospheric ducts form at night. The multi-stage conditional ANC curtain activates perimeter, tower-mounted, and rotor-embedded sources in a cascading manner depending on wind speed, shear exponent, and park operating mode. This hierarchy saved 1.8 GWh per year on a 50-turbine array compared with permanent 2 dB curtailment, illustrating the value of conditional deployment.

---

5. Psycho-Acoustic Masking and Amplitude-Modulation Control

Successful control of broadband components has elevated the relative prominence of residual tones and blade-pass modulation. Rather than canceling those features outright, operators can mask or decorrelate them so that they drop below the thresholds established in ISO 1996-3.

5.1 Selective Tonal Masking

The selective, frequency-confined tonal masking architecture installs two concentric ring arrays of ribbon tweeters on the nacelle roof. DSP identifies tones within ±10 Hz of gearmesh or generator tooth frequencies and injects narrowband pink noise of the same bandwidth aimed at the receptor direction. Because the mask is no wider than 20 Hz, total radiated sound power increases by less than 0.6 dB while subjective prominence drops by up to 5 dB according to DIN 45681-B weighting.

5.2 Directional Masking Beams

When receptors are clustered on one side of the site, the yaw-adaptive directional masking beam forms a cardioid lobe that tracks nacelle yaw to keep the masking signal aligned with the community. Alternatively, it can stay stationary so that as the turbine yaws the natural noise field sometimes self-masks the tone and the artificial beam can power down to save energy.

5.3 Amplitude-Modulation Depth Flattening

Amplitude modulation or "thump" arises when phase-locked rotors reinforce one another at a fixed receptor. Micro-modulation of rotor speed by ±1 RPM reduces modulation depth by up to 40 percent but can disturb grid code compliance. Masking methods avoid that conflict. By combining a 1 dB broadband masking increase with a 3 dB notch in the modulation frequency via rotor phase desynchronisation (see Section 6.2), perceptual annoyance falls below the 2 dBAM threshold used in several European regulations.

---

6. Coordinated Turbine and Plant-Level Operation

Single-turbine mitigations accumulate but cannot fully address cooperative effects in large arrays. Plant-wide controllers use wake interactions, phase management, and acoustic beamforming to keep overall sound power within the park’s envelope while retaining revenue.

6.1 Wake-Mediated Tonal Control and Collaborative Noise Shaping

The wake-mediated plant-level tonal control algorithm first localises the turbine whose tone dominates at the critical receptor by combining SCADA speed data with propagation models. It then redistributes torque set-points among upwind machines to slightly alter the incident turbulence on the noisy turbine. The complementary multi-turbine collaborative noise shaping routine can also elevate benign broadband noise from quieter turbines to psycho-acoustically mask the offender, achieving compliance without curtailment. A six-turbine cluster tested in Denmark maintained IEC 61400-14 noise limits with a 0.5 percent AEP penalty, compared to 3 percent under classical derating.

6.2 Phase Desynchronisation for Modulation Control

The phase-desynchronized rotor management algorithm monitors blade-pass pulses via nacelle accelerometers and injects micro-adjustments to rotor speed so that peaks from neighboring machines arrive out-of-phase at the receptor. Gut-level power remains unchanged because each rotor steps only 0.2 RPM away from optimum. A 15-turbine row reduced thump level by 3 dB at 800 m distance during downwind operation without measurable AEP impact.

6.3 Predictive Acoustic-Vibration Correlation

Linking detection to action, the acoustic-vibration correlation predictor cross-correlates a grid of nacelle accelerometers with park microphones and operational data. It forecasts tonal audibility up to ten minutes ahead, giving the supervisory controller time to decide whether to deploy wake shaping, phase desynchronisation, or hybrid masking. Early warning reduced the need for last-moment blanket curtailment by 60 percent in a two-month field trial, proving the financial value of predictive intelligence.

---

7. Signal Processing, Reference Construction, and Control Stability

All active systems hinge on reference quality and filter stability. Poor coherence reduces achievable attenuation, while adaptive filter divergence can produce dangerous pressure spikes.

7.1 Beamformed, High-Resolution References

The beamformed reference signal using LCMP and quadratic interpolation replaces single microphones with a six-element linear array mounted inside the nacelle. A linearly constrained minimum power beamformer zeros out contributions from the cancellation loudspeaker and gearbox reflections, isolating the primary rotor harmonic. Windowed FFT followed by quadratic peak interpolation tracks frequency with sub-0.2 Hz resolution and reconstructs a time-domain reference that leads the disturbance by 15 degrees, sufficient for aggressive feed-forward control. Coherence improved from 0.4 to 0.85 on a 3 MW prototype, doubling broadband attenuation.

7.2 Frequency-Domain Divergence Suppression

Feedback paths in large structures vary with temperature and yaw angle. The frequency-domain divergence-suppression weight control architecture collapses the classic twin adaptive loops into a single complex LMS filter that runs in the frequency domain. A supervisory monitor checks every bin for error energy surges; if a threshold is crossed due to path change, the corresponding weights scale back instantly, avoiding the howling events that plague large loudspeakers in confined towers. Test data on a prototype showed unconditional stability over 24 hours of storm-induced rotor speed variation, with only a 1 dB sacrifice in average attenuation compared to an unconstrained baseline.

7.3 Implementation Footprint

Running the above algorithms for a 20-speaker perimeter array needs roughly 16 GFLOPs, well within a modern industrial FPGA. Latency budgets remain below 5 ms, compatible with low-frequency timing, and memory fits in 512 MB of DDR3. OEMs therefore bundle ANC DSP into the existing edge computer that also hosts pitch and yaw control, limiting BoP additions to audio amplifiers and cabling.

The signal processing layer completes the control hierarchy, furnishing robust references for blade-scale actuators all the way to park-wide phase managers while protecting against instabilities that could otherwise trigger automatic shutdowns.