Minimizing 3D Print Deformation Through Process Optimization
16 patents in this list
Updated:
In additive manufacturing, dimensional accuracy is compromised by thermal gradients, residual stresses, and material phase changes. Parts experience volumetric changes of up to 2% during printing and post-processing, with particularly significant deformation occurring in overhanging features and areas of concentrated thermal input. These effects manifest as warping, cracking, and dimensional inaccuracies that can render precision parts unusable.
The fundamental challenge lies in managing the complex interplay between thermal history, material properties, and geometric constraints throughout the build process and subsequent thermal treatments.
This page brings together solutions from recent research—including heat-aware toolpath optimization, substrate material selection for thermal management, predictive distortion compensation, and advanced material formulations with controlled shrinkage behavior. These and other approaches provide practical strategies for achieving dimensional accuracy in additive manufacturing while maintaining production efficiency.
1. 3D Metal Printing Method Using Tacky Polymer Substrate with Low Thermal Conductivity
HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P., 2023
3D printing metal objects without warping or cracking by using a tacky polymer substrate. The process involves spreading a layer of metal particles over a polymer substrate with low thermal conductivity and melting the unmasked metal with pulsed light to form each layer of the object. The polymer substrate reduces lateral heat transfer during melting, preventing warping and cracking.
2. 3D Printing Material Comprising Monofunctional Acrylate Monomers and UV Absorbing Initiators for Dental Models
SHOFU INC., 2023
A 3D printing material for dental applications that allows the fast production of accurate dental models. The material contains specific monomers and initiators that reduce polymerization shrinkage and deformation after printing. The key components are monofunctional acrylate monomers with an electronegativity difference of less than 1.0 between adjacent atoms and initiators with absorption bands of 350-450nm. The material may also include low-shrinkage polyfunctional methacrylates, non-dendritic polymers, fillers, and colorants.
3. Method for Generating Distortion-Compensated Geometry in 3D-Printed Parts Using Predictive Node Displacement Adjustment
General Electric Company, 2023
Generating distortion-compensated geometry for a workpiece by predicting and compensating for sintering-induced distortion in 3D-printed parts. The method involves comparing a post-sintering mesh to a model mesh, determining node displacements, and moving corresponding nodes in the green body mesh opposite to the predicted sintering displacement directions. The green body mesh is iteratively adjusted until the predicted post-sintering geometry meets the desired tolerances.
4. Toolpath Generation with Heat Management for 3D Printing
Siemens Industry Software Inc., 2023
Heat-aware toolpath generation for 3D printing of physical objects. The toolpath is generated with criteria that optimize the path to minimize heat accumulation and deformation during the print. The toolpath design accounts for factors like the amount of heat generated in a zone, the proximity to previously printed zones, and the time between printing zones to strategically plan the order and placement of printed paths. This reduces heat-related deformations and improves the quality of printed objects.
5. 3D Printing Method Using Grooved Support Structures for Constraining Sintering-Induced Distortion in Metal Parts
SEIKO EPSON CORPORATION, 2023
A 3D printing technique for reducing distortion in sintered metal parts made from powdered metal and binder. The method involves using a shaped support structure with grooves into which the part's projections fit. When the part is heated to sinter the metal powder, the support constrains the shrinkage direction to prevent distortion.
6. Additively Manufactured Cranial Remodeling Device with Customized Layered Structure and Integrated Functional Elements
CRANIAL TECHNOLGIES, INC, 2023
A cranial remodeling device to correct a deformed head of a subject. The device has layers conforming to the head shape and is additively manufactured using a data file derived from 3D scans of the subject's head. The technique captures head shape data, modifies it to a desired shape, and projects contour lines onto the modified shape to design the device. The additive manufacturing process prints customized layers with removable supports at the point of service. This enables accurate, one-step, in-clinic production of cranial devices without shipping delays. The technique can further include printing alignment marks, sensors, transducers, and fasteners for enhanced functionality.
7. Ceramic 3D Printing System with Controlled Solvent and Binder Interactions for Layer Stabilization
Kiichi Kamoda, Hiroki Hagiwara, 2023
A method and apparatus for producing ceramic 3D printed objects with improved shape accuracy while preventing deformation and bleeding during shaping. The method uses secondary particles with a specific bulk density range, a solvent with a boiling point range, and binder resin with a specific energy difference to adjust solubility and drying rates. This balances the dissolution of the binder with drying to stabilize each layer.
8. 3D Printing Material Composition with Thermoplastic Resin, Elastomer, and Filler for Warp and Deformation Suppression
MITSUI CHEMICALS, INC., PRIME POLYMER CO., LTD., 2022
Suppression of warping and deformation in 3D-printed objects. The method involves using a specific material composition for 3D printing that contains thermoplastic resin, thermoplastic elastomer, and filler (like talc). The filler content is 5-70% by weight of the material. This material reduces warping and deformation when 3D-printed compared to conventional materials. The method involves melting and extruding the material to print objects.
9. Method for Inserting Green Body Projections into Grooved Support Structure for Uniform Sintering Shrinkage
SEIKO EPSON CORPORATION, 2021
Three-dimensional shaping method to prevent distortion of sintered 3D printed objects. The method involves inserting the projections of a green body into grooves of a support structure before sintering. The grooves extend in a specified direction of shrinkage. This allows the green body to shrink uniformly without being distorted during sintering.
10. 3D Printing Method Utilizing Variable Material Supply for Initial Layer on Recessed Stage
Seiko Epson Corporation, 2020
3D printing objects with better dimensional accuracy and reduced warpage. It involves using a first supply amount of material larger than a second supply amount when printing the first layer on a stage with a recessed portion. This prevents voids and unevenness in the layer caused by material entering the recessed part.
11. 3D Printing Method with Temperature-Controlled Initial Layer Stress Management
PANASONIC INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT CO., LTD., 2019
A method for 3D printing objects that reduces warping and deformation by controlling the temperature during printing. The method involves printing the initial layers on a heated build plate to create outward stress that counteracts the inward stress from subsequent layers. This reduces deformation of the final printed object compared to uniform temperature printing.
12. Layer-by-Layer 3D Printing Using Directed Energy Beam for Solid Tile Formation
Velo3D, Inc., 2019
improvement in 3D printing of large objects with reduced deformation and without auxiliary supports. The method involves printing the object layer by layer using a directed energy beam. The beam irradiates small stationary areas on the bed surface to transform the material into solid tiles, without transforming the surrounding material. By overlapping the tiles, it builds up the object without deforming or requiring supports.
13. 3D Printing Method with Sequential Base Plate Heating and Flattening to Mitigate Warping
Satoshi Abe, Norio Yoshida, Isao Fuwa, 2018
Manufacturing method for 3D printing objects that reduces warping. The method involves flattening a base plate before and after printing to counteract warping. The base plate is initially heated to warp it, then flattened. After printing, the base plate is reheated and flattened again. This counters stresses that can cause warping when the object is removed from the base plate.
14. Layered 3D Printing with Stationary Overlapping Tile-Based Energy Beam Transformation
VELO3D, INC., 2018
3D printing without supports and with reduced deformation by using stationary, low power, overlapping tiles to transform exposed material layer by layer. The method involves a directed energy beam that transforms exposed material at one position, then translating to another position without transforming, and transforming again. This builds the object layer by layer without moving parts. It reduces deformation and allows unsupported overhangs. The stationary, overlapping tiles avoid the deformation caused by continuous scanning.
15. 3D Printing Process with Energy Beam-Induced Tile Formation for Deformation Control
Velo3D, Inc., 2018
3D printing method to generate objects with control over deformation during printing. The method involves selectively transforming portions of a material bed using energy beams to form individual "tiles" of transformed material that harden into the final object. By adjusting beam parameters and tile locations, the method can reduce bending deformation during printing. The tiles can overlap or contact to form a continuous object.
16. 3D Printing Method with Continuous Scanning Paths and Adjustable Beam Diameter
Matsuura Machinery Corporation, 2015
Avoiding warpage in 3D printed objects by using continuous scanning paths and controlling beam diameter. The paths that the scanning beam takes inside the printed object are set to be continuous without intersecting or retracing steps. This prevents uneven heating and cooling. The beam diameter is also adjusted to optimize sintering quality.
Request the PDF report with complete details of all 16 patents for offline reading.
A diverse range of solutions are emerging to address the challenge of deformationᅳfrom using tacky polymer substrates to heat-aware toolpath optimization, these techniques offer users a toolbox to mitigate warping, cracking, and shrinkage during the printing process.