10 patents in this list

Updated:

Citation networks in patent analysis routinely encompass thousands of documents with complex interdependencies. A typical technology domain may contain over 10,000 patent families, each with multiple citation layers spanning decades of innovation. Understanding these relationships is crucial for portfolio valuation, prior art analysis, and strategic patent prosecution.

The fundamental challenge lies in extracting meaningful insights from citation networks while maintaining both computational efficiency and analytical accuracy across large document sets.

This page brings together solutions from recent research—including automated citation landscape generation, recursive relevance scoring methods, claim-based reference mapping, and business context-aware evaluation systems. These and other approaches focus on practical tools that help patent practitioners navigate complex citation networks while making informed prosecution and portfolio management decisions.

1. System for Automatic Generation of Patent Citation Landscapes with Aggregated Backward Citation Analysis

Black Hills IP Holdings, LLC, 2023

Automatic generation of patent citation landscapes for comprehensive analysis of patent family connections and citations to identify problematic patents and analyze portfolio value. The system identifies related patents in a family, and searches and aggregates backward citations for analysis.

US20230274374A1-patent-drawing

2. Wireless Patent Search and Analytics Tool with Claim Analysis, Citation Network Link Structure, and Classification Integration

ERICH LAWSON SPANGENBERG, DANIEL LAWRENCE BORK, PASCAL ASSELOT, 2022

Wireless worldwide patent search and analytics tool that can be used for the search of undiscovered and undiscovered patents. The tool analyzes the claims under consideration (query claim of query patent), the text of the art, the link structure of the citation network, and the patent classification.

3. Recursive Citation Analysis System for Document Relevance Scoring

Emory University, 2020

Automatically finding relevant documents for a given set of documents by analyzing citation information. The method involves recursively processing citation information of the queried documents to find citing documents, then processing citation information of the citing documents to find further cited documents. Relevance scores are computed for the cited documents based on how they are cited by the citing documents. Relevant documents are determined based on direct citation relevance from the original query documents, and indirect citation relevance from the recursive search.

4. Automated System for Evaluating Intangible Assets Using Patent Citations and Business Context Data

ASTAMUSE COMPANY, LTD., 2020

Automated methods for evaluating intangible assets like patents that leverage business context to provide a more pragmatic evaluation. The method uses data on patent citations, applicant company values, and inter-company relationships. It retrieves evaluation indices for cited patent applicants and then modifies the original patent's evaluation index based on those. This accounts for business value and relationships in assessing a patent's worth.

US10579651B1-patent-drawing

5. Patent Management System with Integrated Analytics and Visualization Tools for Prosecution, Reference, Docketing, Claim Mapping, Portfolio, and Annuity Management

Black Hills IP Holdings, LLC, 2014

Patent management system with tools for analyzing patents and patent applications. The system provides analytics and visualization features to help make decisions at each stage of a patient's life. Tools include prosecution analytics to evaluate success rates based on factors like claim length, rejection type, and prior art ownership; reference management to analyze cited references; docketing management to track deadlines; claim mapping to view claim history; portfolio analytics to monitor patent growth; and annuity management to analyze maintenance fees. The system aims to provide decision support for patent prosecution, maintenance, and management using data analysis and visualization.

US20140052650A1-patent-drawing

6. Reference Management System with Clan-Based Grouping and Automated Prior Art Association

Faegre Baker Daniels LLP, 2013

Reference management tool for tracking prior art references associated with patent applications. The tool allows users to associate patent applications (matters) into user-defined groups called clans. It automatically associates references between clans to find similar subject matter. The tool also generates Information Disclosure Statements (IDSs) and allows review and notification.

7. Method for Rating Patent Importance via Similarity Analysis with External Sources

Steven W. Lundberg, 2013

Automatically rating the importance of patents in a portfolio by comparing their similarity to third-party websites and literature. The method involves determining the degree of overlap between a patent specification/claims and external sources, such as competitor websites or product manuals. This overlap score is used to rate the patent's importance in the portfolio. Comparing importance scores across patents helps inform annuity payment decisions.

8. System for Categorizing and Visualizing Patent Concepts with Interactive Ranking and Mapping

Steven W. Lundberg, 2013

Patent mapping, ranking, and rating system for analyzing patents quickly by categorizing patents and claims into concepts, ranking the concepts, and visualizing the relationships between concepts and claims. The system allows users to map patents and claims to concepts, track ranking data for concepts, and generate interactive charts to analyze the patent portfolio.

US20130086070A1-patent-drawing

9. Patent Management System for Analyzing and Mapping Prior Art Reference Overlap Across Entities

Steven W. Lundberg, 2013

A patent management system for analyzing prior art, identifying common references cited against multiple entities, mapping the references, and displaying the prior art overlap to a user. The system uses databases to store cited references, identifies sets cited against target and other entities, maps the sets for overlap, and presents the shared references to the user. It can also identify reference owners and competitors.

US20130086093A1-patent-drawing

10. System for Cross-Referencing Intellectual Property Claims with Amendment and Examination Status Tracking

IP DEVELOPMENT VENTURE, 2011

Cross-referencing important intellectual property relationships to help patent practitioners efficiently understand and manage claims in patent applications. The system provides a structured way to track and display claims, their amendment status, examination status, and prior art. It allows searching and filtering claims based on scope to find ones of interest. This helps practitioners advise clients, draft claims, and avoid prosecution costs by having a concise and organized view of claims.

Request the PDF report with complete details of all 10 patents for offline reading.

These patents demonstrate a number of developments in mapping and citation analysis technologies. Automating the process of creating patent landscapes or finding pertinent patents is the focus of some inventions. Others solve the relevance problem by creating tools to evaluate citation data and find relevant documents.