Evaluating intellectual property requires analyzing thousands of existing patents, trademarks, and other IP assets across multiple jurisdictions and time periods. A single invention assessment typically involves reviewing 50-100 closely related patents, analyzing their claims structures, and mapping technical overlap—a process that traditionally takes 15-20 hours of expert review.

The fundamental challenge lies in systematically evaluating novelty and non-obviousness while accounting for the rapid evolution of technology and the growing complexity of prior art.

This page brings together solutions from recent research—including machine learning approaches for patent comparison, automated trademark clearance systems, and AI-powered invention evaluation frameworks. These and other approaches aim to increase evaluation accuracy and reduce assessment time while maintaining the rigorous standards required for IP protection.

1. University Intellectual Property Management Platform with Real-Time Innovation Project Data Collection and Scalability Evaluation

ANHUI DIJIA INFORMATION TECH CO LTD, ANHUI DIJIA INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CO LTD, 2023

Intellectual property management platform for universities to improve intellectual property education and value creation. The platform collects real-time data on teacher-student innovation projects, expands keywords, evaluates scalability, and provides guidance. Teachers divide project stages and set standards. It connects to teacher terminals to collect innovation process data, expands keywords, evaluates scalability, and provides guidance. The platform extracts relevant keywords from patents and databases to assess project potential. The goal is to enhance IP understanding, design, and value through data analysis.

2. Intellectual Property Data Platform Utilizing Natural Language Processing for Data Categorization and Analysis

ZIPLE CO LTD, 2023

Intellectual property data platform that provides enhanced intellectual property management services by processing, categorizing, and analyzing intellectual property data using natural language processing techniques. The platform collects intellectual property information from sources, preprocesses and analyzes the text, measures similarity, learns categories, and stores labeled data. It then offers services like schedule management, prior art search, and reports using the processed data. The platform customizes patent attorney recommendations and tech trend insights based on user fields.

KR20230139108A-patent-drawing

3. Computer System with Machine Learning Algorithms for Invention Evaluation and Prioritization

Markison Patent Portal, Inc., 2023

An improved computer for technology that calculates and reports on inventions in order to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of technology innovation and protection. The computer uses machine learning and artificial intelligence programs to identify, evaluate, and prioritize inventions across a range of metrics including commercial potential, patentability, integration opportunities, and competitor targeting.

4. Big Data-Driven System with Modular Architecture for Technology Innovation Management in Enterprises

CHINA DATANG CORP SCI & TECH RES INST CO LTD, CHINA DATANG CORPORATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH INSTITUTE CO LTD, 2023

A big data-based system to manage technology innovation in large enterprises. The system has modules for resource management, project management, declaration management, intellectual property management, data management, and assessment management. It provides a dynamic innovation data center and communication platform to coordinate technological direction, process management, and implementation. The system leverages big data integration to informatize basic management, digitize in-depth management, and intelligentize advanced management of technology innovation.

CN116308116A-patent-drawing

5. Innovation Evaluation System with Geographic Novelty Assessment and Multi-Factor Categorization Subsystems

GT CONSULTORIA E INOVACAO PESQUISA E DESENVOLVIMENTO DE SIST LTDA, GT CONSULTORIA E INOVACAO PESQUISA E DESENVOLVIMENTO DE SISTEMAS LTDA, 2023

A system to objectively evaluate and categorize innovation content to minimize subjectivity and risk in innovation analysis. The system has two subsystems: one to assess the scope of innovation based on geographic novelty levels, and another to categorize based on factors like innovation degree, activity nature, engagement, and barriers.

6. Integrated Intellectual Property Management System with Interconnected Decision Analysis and Due Diligence Modules

DELTA TECH KOREA LLC, DELTA TECH-KOREA LLC, 2022

Corporate intellectual property management system that helps companies make informed decisions about patent rights by analyzing the value and strategic fit of their intellectual property. The system interconnects a company, research teams, and patent agents to manage IP projects, provide quotations, and conduct patent asset due diligence. It generates services like government project recommendations, agent selection, and IP management based on matching IP project plans and agent experience. Due diligence involves guidelines, map analysis, and prediction to classify IP as keep, license, or discard.

KR20220124529A-patent-drawing

7. Method for Evaluating Innovation Stability of Enterprises Using Intellectual Property Portfolio Analysis

CHINA CONSTRUCTION BANK CORP, 2022

Method for accurately evaluating the innovation stability of scientific and technological enterprises by leveraging their intellectual property portfolios. The method involves obtaining the intellectual property information associated with the enterprise, determining the total amount of innovation in each cycle based on the number and weight of IP types, and then evaluating the innovation stability based on the staged stability of each IP type. This allows evaluating innovation stability more accurately by directly assessing the enterprise's IP generation over time rather than relying solely on financial data.

8. Multi-Stage Technology and Idea Commercialization Feasibility Evaluation System

CHOI HOON SHIK, 2022

A system for evaluating the feasibility of technology development and idea commercialization. The system involves a multi-stage evaluation process that requests prior patent evaluation, technology feasibility evaluation, project feasibility evaluation, and comprehensive commercialization feasibility evaluation. It allows to evaluate whether commercializing a technology idea is appropriate by requesting expert evaluations at each stage. The evaluations are based on factors like patent analysis, market trends, industry attractiveness, business models, and net present value calculations.

KR20220046942A-patent-drawing

9. Intellectual Property Valuation System Utilizing Database-Driven Technological and Financial Metrics Analysis

CHOI HOON SHIK, 2022

A system for evaluating the technical value of intellectual property rights that provides a more reliable and objective way to calculate the value of intangible assets like patents. The system uses data from intellectual property and financial statement databases to evaluate factors like technological contribution, business feasibility, and industry discount rates to determine the value of the intellectual property. It involves steps like estimating the industrial importance of the technology, evaluating the degree of technological contribution, calculating discount rates and annual free cash flow, and finally determining the technology value.

KR20220046943A-patent-drawing

10. Method for Intellectual Property Rights Management via Enterprise Resource Planning Systems

XIAMEN SCIENCE AND ENG COLLEGE, XIAMEN SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING COLLEGE, 2022

A method for managing intellectual property (IP) rights using enterprise resource planning (ERP) software. The method involves using ERP systems to manage and analyze a company's own technology, decide whether to patent it, estimate the potential value, and determine the patent maintenance period. This allows smaller companies with limited resources to better assess and optimize their IP strategy compared to full patent evaluations.

11. System for Technology Transfer with Modules for Evaluation and Achievement Docking

YUANXIAO TECHNOLOGY ACHIEVEMENT TRANSF SERVICE CO LTD, YUANXIAO TECHNOLOGY ACHIEVEMENT TRANSFORMATION SERVICE CO LTD, 2022

A system to facilitate transfer and transformation of scientific and technological achievements that addresses the challenges of matching supply and demand of technology. The system has modules for technology evaluation, demand evaluation, and achievement docking. It aims to improve technology transfer efficiency by assessing the technical merit and demand feasibility of technologies, then matching them. This allows more targeted and successful technology transfers compared to traditional patent-based approaches. The system also provides features like intellectual property stability assessment and pricing models to mitigate risks and trust issues in technology transfers.

12. Automated System for Structured Analysis of Technology Viability and Corporate Management Using Data-Driven Phases and Metrics

SPG HOLDING, LLC, 2022

Automated work system for analyzing technology, intellectual property, and corporate management for commercialization of new businesses. The system provides a repeatable and focused method for starting, building, and launching a new company that reduces risk, cost, and time to success. It uses automated data collection and analysis from web crawlers, databases, and enterprise tools to assess market needs, technology viability, innovation potential, and management effectiveness. The system has phases with goals, milestones, and confidence scores to track progress and make recommendations. It generates insights, alerts, and reports for each phase and functionality area. The system also provides automated recommendations for improvement. The goal is to objectively and systematically evaluate and bring technologies to market with lower risk, cost, and time compared to traditional methods.

13. Automated Knowledge Generation and Documentation System with Structured Ideation and Novelty Assessment

GROUNDED LEARNING M SDN BHD, GROUNDED LEARNING SDN BHD, 2021

System to manage new knowledge generation in a research project and automatically document the process for publication purposes while tracking potential novelty. The system involves structured ideation steps for research proposal planning, critical literature review, theoretical synthesis, and abstract creation. It also assesses potential novelty at each stage. The system captures user decisions from tangible sources like articles, allowing quick reference without re-reading. This expedited referral process saves time compared to directly accessing articles. The system's embedded assessment method forecasts potential intellectual property from the research.

WO2021251815A1-patent-drawing

14. Innovation Management Platform with Idea Submission, Evaluation, and Sponsorship Features

DOGUS BILGI ISLEM VE TEKNOLOJI HIZMETLERI ANONIM SIRKETI, Doğuş Information Processing and Technology Services Joint Stock Company, 2021

A platform for innovation management and idea evaluation that enables sharing, development, and sponsorship of innovation ideas within and between companies. The platform allows employees to submit and view innovation ideas, provide comments and evaluations, and find sponsors for their ideas. It also provides tools for defining problems, identifying necessary actions, and evaluating ideas using various models.

15. Intellectual Property Management System with Incubation, Formation, and Evolution Modules for Scientific Research Projects

SHANGHAI INST TECH, SHANGHAI INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, 2021

A system for managing intellectual property (IP) incubation, formation, and evolution in scientific research projects. The system aims to better manage IP in research projects, especially major national projects, to facilitate commercialization and strategic importance. It has three modules: incubation during project approval to identify potential IP, formation during acceptance to develop stable IP systems, and evolution after acceptance for IP commercialization and monitoring. The modules involve steps like IP project evaluation, achievement management, thematic database, and IP analysis/protection.

CN112991106A-patent-drawing

16. Enterprise Patent Lifecycle Management System with Modules for Innovation Evaluation, Application Approval, Market Analysis, and Implementation Monitoring

NANJING CHANGYUAN INFORMATION TECH CO LTD, NANJING CHANGYUAN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CO LTD, 2021

Enterprise patent full life cycle management system that enables effective management of patents from ideation to commercialization. The system has modules for evaluating technological innovation, approving patent applications, obtaining market information, and monitoring patent implementation to maximize patent value. This comprehensive approach helps enterprises generate high-quality patents, secure strong protection, commercialize patents, and optimize patent management throughout the lifecycle.

17. Framework for Analyzing Intangible Assets Using Qualitative and Quantitative Metrics

AON RISK SERVICES INC OF MARYLAND, 2021

Analyzing intangible assets like intellectual property using a framework to provide meaningful information to organizations. The framework involves qualitative and quantitative analysis of intangible assets like patents to determine metrics like coverage, opportunity, and risk. It involves identifying factors like claim strength, market size, and litigation probability. This allows assessing the overall value of intangible assets beyond just monetary worth.

18. Method for Evaluating Intellectual Property Asset Value Using Categorized Cost Aggregation and Profit Contribution Analysis

INST OF SCIENCE AND DEVELOPMENT CHINESE ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE AND DEVELOPMENT CHINESE ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, 2021

An intellectual property value evaluation method that accurately reflects the true value of intellectual property assets by categorizing and adding the costs of technical and identification intellectual property rights based on technical and management elements. It calculates the contribution of technology and identification IP to corporate profit, then adds the total cost of both types to get the IP asset value. This considers the future market revenue and encourages independent innovation. The method involves categorizing technical IP costs, adding them, categorizing identification IP costs, adding them, calculating IP contribution to profit, and combining totals.

19. Enterprise Intellectual Property Performance Analysis System Utilizing Big Data Techniques

JIANGSU PATENT INFORMATION SERVICE CENTER, JIANGSU PATENT INFORMATION SERVICE CENTER JIANGSU INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS PROT AND AID CENTER, 2021

A system for analyzing and evaluating the intellectual property (IP) performance of enterprises using big data techniques. The system collects and stores enterprise and IP data, allows users to search and analyze it, and provides insights into areas like IP creation, technical direction, collaboration, and management level. The analysis helps enterprises measure their innovation and IP management capabilities, and provides decision-making support for governments monitoring regional IP development.

20. System for Quantitative Evaluation and Ranking of Technology Classifications in R&D Investment Allocation

Korea Research Foundation, 2020

Method for deriving R&D investment fields using a system that efficiently allocates R&D budgets by quantitatively evaluating technology classifications. The system collects expert evaluations of factors like performance, maturity, and future value for each tech classification. It calculates a tech investment score for each classification by combining the expert assessments. When requested, the system provides R&D investment recommendations by ranking classifications based on their calculated scores.

KR102185014B1-patent-drawing

21. Automated Patent Evaluation System Utilizing Edit Distance-Based Sentence Comparison

AI Samurai Inc., 2020

A patent evaluation system that determines the patentability of an invention idea. The system uses an automated process to compare an invention sentence with existing patent sentences using an edit distance measure. The comparison looks for similar sentences in a patent sentence database. The determination of patentability is based on multiplying the reciprocal of the edit distance with the length index of the invention sentence and the content rate of the keyword.

22. Intellectual Property Financial System with Validation, Evaluation, and Financing Modules

JIANGXI YUFUBAO INTERNET TECH CO LTD, JIANGXI YUFUBAO INTERNET TECHNOLOGY CO LTD, 2020

Intellectual property financial system to improve the quality and transparency of buying, selling, and financing intellectual property assets like patents, trademarks, and copyrights. The system involves a review module to validate IP data, an evaluation module to estimate value using cost, market, and income analysis, and a financing module for IP-backed loans. It aims to prevent low-quality, fake IP from entering the market, provide better financial services for IP transactions, and improve IP asset valuation and transfer methods.

23. Intellectual Property Transformation Management System with Resource Integration, Evaluation, and Investment Modules

JIANGXI SINOSTAR INTERNET TECH CO LTD, JIANGXI SINOSTAR INTERNET TECHNOLOGY CO LTD, 2020

Intellectual property achievement transformation management system to facilitate commercialization of intellectual property (IP) by addressing the factors that restrict IP transformation. The system includes modules for IP resource integration, achievement management, evaluation, investment finance, and result exchange. It aims to improve IP transformation by addressing issues like imperfect systems, information asymmetry, immature IP, lack of funding, and support. The system collects IP data, evaluates transformability, provides financing options, and connects IP holders with investors.

24. System and Method for Patent-Driven Technology Commercialization with Multi-Application Analysis and Equity Management

KIM JAE MOON, 2020

A commercialization development system and method using patents to improve the success rate of technology commercialization and standardize the process. It leverages patent information, additional data, and expert diagnosis to recommend optimal commercialization models. The system provides a platform for technology providers to identify application fields, generate project ideas, and connect with investors. It also manages equity conversion, valuation, and trading. The method involves analyzing patent prior art, identifying multi-application fields, and matching consumer needs. It calculates commercialization factors, converts equity based on valuation, and tracks performance.

25. Intellectual Property Document Evaluation System with Case and Value Assessment Modules

SUZHOU LIEHUZUO TECH INNOVATION SERVICE CO LTD, SUZHOU LIEHUZUO TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION SERVICE CO LTD, 2020

A system for comparing and evaluating intellectual property documents to provide an automated and standardized way to assess the value of intellectual property assets. The system includes a client application for entering IP document details and a server with modules for case evaluation and value evaluation. The case evaluation module analyzes factors like novelty, inventiveness, and industrial applicability. The value evaluation module determines the monetary worth based on factors like market demand, competition, and potential royalties.

CN110728130A-patent-drawing

26. Sequential Evaluation Method for Objective Valuation of Patented Technologies Using Technical and Litigation Data

KYONGGI UNIV INDUSTRY & ACADEMIA COOPERATION FOUNDATION, KYONGGI UNIVERSITY INDUSTRY & ACADEMIA COOPERATION FOUNDATION, 2019

Method for objective evaluation and trading of patented technologies. The method involves using technical evaluators to provide objective valuations of patented technologies. This involves presenting the evaluators with the technology and relevant patent trial and litigation data. The evaluators then evaluate the technology value. By forcing sequential evaluation and penalizing non-compliance, it compels faithful evaluations. The valuations are collected and analyzed to determine the technology value. This provides objective valuations for trading patented technologies.

27. System for Automated Selection of Intellectual Property Evaluation Methods with Investment Activation Indicator Calculation

KTG CO LTD, 2019

Method for evaluating the technical value of intellectual property using a system that automatically selects the optimal evaluation method based on the technology being valued. The system provides multiple evaluation methods like market approach, cost approach, and royalty deduction, and finds the most appropriate one for the specific technology. It also calculates investment activation indicators that reflect factors like company investment in R&D and technology life cycle compared to similar companies. This provides three-dimensional information to accurately judge the technology for trading decisions.

KR102018679B1-patent-drawing

28. Enterprise Innovation Capability Evaluation System with Integrated Assessment of Production Innovation, Innovation Input, Intellectual Property, and Innovation Driving Ability

Anhui Qianyundu Information Technology Co., Ltd., 2018

A comprehensive system for evaluating enterprise innovation capability using four aspects: production innovation, innovation input, intellectual property, and innovation driving ability. It provides a more complete and scientific evaluation of enterprise innovation compared to existing methods. The four aspects cover different aspects of innovation like applying innovative ideas/tech in production, investing in innovation, creating/protecting IP, and realizing innovation value.

CN108288127A-patent-drawing

29. AI-Driven Patent Search and Valuation System with Machine Learning Models and TRIZ-Based Analysis

Darae Strategic Commercialization Center, 2018

Patent trend analysis system that uses AI and machine learning to provide automated patent search, analysis, and valuation services. The system collects patent data, develops machine learning models for search, analysis, and valuation, and provides web applications for users to access the services. It expands user search queries, guides more relevant keywords, performs patent analysis using TRIZ design principles, and values patents based on factors like aesthetics, brand, and environment.

30. Automated Intellectual Property Valuation System with Modular Analysis Components

SUZHOU DACHENG YOUFANG DATA TECH CO LTD, SUZHOU DACHENG YOUFANG DATA TECHNOLOGY CO LTD, Suzhou Dacheng Youfang Data Technology Co., Ltd., 2018

A system to efficiently evaluate the value of intellectual property (IP) rights using automated modules. The system involves four modules: 1) input fee statistical module to analyze historical IP registration fees, 2) innovation evaluation module to assess the novelty and originality of the IP, 3) maturity evaluation module to determine the stage of development of the IP, and 4) market appraisal module to analyze factors like market size, competition, and demand. The system provides a preliminary IP valuation based on these assessments and reduces subjectivity compared to manual evaluation.

31. Enterprise Innovation Capability Evaluation System with Four-Level Assessment Framework and Integrated Indicator Modules

Suzhou Dacheng Youfang Data Technology Co., Ltd., 2017

A system for evaluating the innovation capability of enterprises using a four-level assessment framework with indicators that comprehensively measure innovation inputs, synergistic innovation, intellectual property, and innovation drive. The system has modules for assessing innovation funding, capabilities, institutions, cooperation, creation, protection, and use of intellectual property. This holistic approach provides a more accurate and effective way to evaluate enterprise innovation compared to isolated assessments of individual aspects.

CN107506900A-patent-drawing

32. Modular Intellectual Property Valuation System with Multi-Criteria Assessment Modules

SUZHOU DACHENGYOUFANG DATA TECH CO LTD, SUZHOU DACHENGYOUFANG DATA TECHNOLOGY CO LTD, 2017

An intellectual property (IP) value evaluation system to provide a preliminary IP valuation to reduce errors in final assessments. The system involves breaking down IP valuation into multiple assessment modules like investment cost, innovation, maturity, market application, implementation ability, monopoly, ownership, and quantity. This allows staff to input basic IP details and get an initial valuation rather than manually evaluating the entire IP. It provides a reference standard to reduce the chance of error in final assessments.

33. Method for Multi-Factor Assessment of Intellectual Property Rights Value

FOSHAN RONGXINTONG ENTERPRISE CONSULTING SERVICE CO LTD, FOSHAN RONGXINTONG ENTPR CONSULTING SERVICE CO LTD, 2016

A method for assessing the value of intellectual property rights that aims to provide a more objective and comprehensive way to determine the value of intellectual property compared to traditional methods. The method involves a multi-step process that considers factors like stability of the IP rights, inventor expertise, field of technology, IP content quality, and more. It aims to provide a more detailed and three-dimensional evaluation of IP value by using disaggregated evaluation and involving stakeholders like inventors, commenters, and the public in the assessment process.

34. Intellectual Property Valuation System with Multi-Dimensional Evaluation and Interactive Modules

FOSHAN RONGXINTONG ENTERPRISE CONSULTING SERVICE CO LTD, FOSHAN RONGXINTONG ENTPR CONSULTING SERVICE CO LTD, 2016

A system for assessing the value of intellectual property rights that provides a more objective, detailed, and comprehensive evaluation compared to traditional methods. The system uses a multi-dimensional approach to evaluate factors like inventor expertise, patent quality, legal status, and market potential. It involves a self-assessment module, management module, expert database, comment/reply/live discussion modules, and reporting/publicity module. This allows a more disaggregated, interactive, and iterative evaluation process compared to the subjective and formal reports of traditional methods.

35. Big Data-Driven Idea Evaluation and Development System with Self-Assessment, Expert Feedback, and Supplier Negotiation Features

(), 2016

An idea fostering and evaluation system that uses big data to help inventors turn their initial concepts into commercially viable products. The system provides self-evaluation tools for inventors to refine their ideas, and expert evaluation to further develop them. It also calculates the achievability of the ideas based on the evaluations. The system links inventors with necessary knowledge and technology providers. A negotiation feature allows inventors to find and contract with suppliers for specific needs. The system also leverages big data analysis to evaluate new ideas based on past success rates.

KR101607993B1-patent-drawing

36. Reverse Auction System for Intellectual Property Services with Agent Bidding and Selection Mechanism

BAE KYU HO, 2015

A reverse auction system for intellectual property services that allows idea providers to select the best conditions from certified IP agents. The system receives ideas seeking protection, allows agents to bid on the work, and lets providers choose the preferred conditions. This provides a competitive marketplace for IP services and allows providers to find agents who offer the best value and expertise. The system also includes steps for prior art search, registration analysis, and progress tracking.

KR20150111192A-patent-drawing

37. Modular System for Scientific Achievement Commercialization Management

SINOIPRO IP MAN AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER CO LTD, SINOIPRO IP MANAGEMENT AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER CO LTD, TONGJI UNIVERSITY, 2015

A system to manage and facilitate the commercialization of scientific and technological achievements. It consists of modules like science result evaluation, patent instructions, market information, transaction structure, contract, and monitoring. The system captures detailed information about scientific discoveries, evaluates their commercial potential, provides patent guidance, connects them to relevant markets, facilitates transactions, generates contracts, and oversees the process to maximize commercialization and value extraction from scientific breakthroughs.

CN104850921A-patent-drawing

38. System and Method for Analyzing Industrial Project Intellectual Property with Modular Evaluation Components

SINOIPRO IP MAN AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER CO LTD, SINOIPRO IP MANAGEMENT AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER CO LTD, TONGJI UNIVERSITY, 2015

A method and system for efficiently analyzing intellectual property (IP) of industrial projects to determine if it provides adequate protection and identify potential issues. The method involves obtaining the project and related IP, analyzing the technology points and patents, and making decisions based on factors like remedies, validity, and patent influence. This helps determine if the IP is sufficient for industrialization and identify areas for improvement. The system has modules for item analysis, decision making, and feedback.

CN104850920A-patent-drawing

39. Innovation and Intellectual Property Management Platform with Crowdsourced Idea Generation and Aggregation Engines

Andrew T. Pham, 2015

A platform for managing innovation and intellectual property that enables crowdsource idea generation, publication, feedback, and recognition. The platform provides a publication engine for users to submit, publish, track, receive feedback, and pay for their ideas. It also has an aggregation engine to relate published ideas and an enterprise engine for managing corporate IP. Features include public recognition awards, a patent petition platform, and an idea-sharing forum.

The innovations that provide demonstrate how technology guarantees precise evaluations and informed decisions. Massive volumes of data can be analyzed by AI-powered systems to determine prospective competitors and evaluate market possibilities. Automated solutions for trademark clearance and suggestions can also expedite the registration procedure.

Get Full Report

Access our comprehensive collection of 39 documents related to this technology