Patent Scoring Algorithm for Assessing Strength and Value
16 patents in this list
Updated:
Patent valuation has historically relied on manual expert analysis, with assessment times averaging 12-15 hours per patent and significant variability between evaluators. Modern portfolios can contain thousands of assets, making comprehensive evaluation both time-intensive and inconsistent when relying solely on human analysis.
The fundamental challenge lies in developing objective, scalable methods to evaluate technical, legal, and commercial patent strength while maintaining accuracy across diverse technology domains.
This page brings together solutions from recent research—including machine learning approaches for claim analysis, natural language processing systems for technical depth assessment, and blockchain-based platforms for decentralized valuation. These and other approaches focus on creating reproducible scoring methods that can handle large patent portfolios while maintaining assessment quality.
1. Computer System with Machine Learning for Invention Evaluation and Patent Process Tracking
Markison Patent Portal, Inc., 2023
Improved computer systems and methods for identifying, evaluating, and protecting inventions that arise from research and development projects. The system uses machine learning and artificial intelligence to score and track aspects of the invention disclosure and patent filing process. It identifies and tracks invention types, problems, solutions, embodiments, portfolios, challenges, concepts, and decisions. The system also scores the quality of patent prosecution and analyzes the likelihood of patent issuance.
2. Patent Claim Analysis and Matching System Using Natural Language Understanding and Machine Learning Techniques
DAYSTROM INFORMATION SYSTEMS, LLC, 2023
More accurate patent searching and analysis using AI, specifically natural language understanding (NLU) and machine learning (ML) techniques, to improve search results and avoid missing relevant patents. The method involves analyzing patent claims and relevant text from a reference document using AI systems to determine the meaning of claim elements and search for matches to rank patents based on how well their claims match the reference document.
3. Decentralized Blockchain-Based Patent Risk Evaluation and Management Platform with Dynamic Insurance Policy Customization
Erich Lawson Spangenberg, Daniel Lawrence Bork, Pascal Asselot, 2023
A decentralized platform for evaluating and managing patent risk using blockchain technology. The platform provides customized insurance policies to cover the risk of patents being invalidated. It uses data analysis to evaluate the likelihood of patents being challenged and adjusts policy premiums and limits accordingly. Users can monitor claims and collect payouts if their patents are invalidated. The platform also allows crowdfunding of patent applications and uses blockchain tokens for transactions and rewards.
4. Neural Network-Based Patent and Corporate Assessment Method Using Input Signal Classification
ANYFIVE.CO.LTD, 2022
A method to objectively assess patents using AI. The method involves obtaining information about the target patent and the corporate that owns it, generating input signals from the obtained data, feeding these signals into pre-trained neural networks to classify the patent and corporate, comparing the network outputs to stored comparison values to assess the patent and corporate, and providing the assessment results.
5. Patent Evaluation Method Utilizing Natural Language Processing and Complex Network Algorithms for Technical Depth and Breadth Analysis
BEIJING INNOVATOR INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD., BEIJING BENYING TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD, BEIJING Z-PARK TECHINA INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SERVICES GROUP, 2021
Patent evaluation method that leverages natural language processing and complex network algorithms to objectively evaluate the depth and breadth of patented technologies and predict the expected life of patents. The method involves collecting patent documents, generating technical points, clustering patents into global industries, and comparing patents with technologies in the global industry to evaluate their value.
6. System for Patent Portfolio Mapping with Conceptual Organization and Interactive Visualization
Black Hills IP Holdings, LLC, 2021
A system for mapping, ranking, and visualizing patents and patent portfolios to analyze patent value, coverage, and related concepts. It uses data structures and analytics to organize patents by concepts like scope, technology category, and ranking. This allows interactive charts to be generated showing relationships between patent claims, concepts, rankings, and metadata like filing date and owner. The system also enables features like automated prior art citation management within portfolios.
7. Patent Analysis System with Automated Scoring and Ranking of Claim Elements and Patents
Proactive Patents, LLC, 2021
A patent analysis system that calculates scores to determine the quality and value of patents in a way that is both automated and consistent across a large patent portfolio. The system calculates scores for individual claim elements and overall patents and then compares those scores against peer patents to provide rankings.
8. Patent Investment System with Debt and Equity Financing, Portfolio Pooling, and Performance Analysis Tools
ERICH LAWSON SPANGENBERG, Brian Joshua Berman, 2021
A combined patent debt and equity financing system that allows investors to invest in patents through loans or equity, and provides tools to analyze and manage patent investments. The system allows the pooling of patents across multiple owners to create diversified portfolios. It also involves a fantasy draft-like game where users can pick patents they think will perform well. The system provides analysis and tracking of patent performance to inform investment decisions.
9. Apparatus for Quantifying Patent Obstruction Using Legal Procedure Data and Post-Obsolescence Cost Calculation
Ichiro Kudo, 2020
Evaluation of the exclusive power of a patent by quantifying the extent to which the patent obstructs third-party businesses. The calculation apparatus extracts legal procedure data from patent histories to determine how obstructive the patent was to third parties and then calculates a post-obsolescence cost based on the filing date. The total post-obsolescence costs across all extracted patents provide an evaluation of patent power.
10. Automated Patent Evaluation System Utilizing Edit Distance-Based Sentence Comparison
AI Samurai Inc., 2020
A patent evaluation system that determines the patentability of an invention idea. The system uses an automated process to compare an invention sentence with existing patent sentences using an edit distance measure. The comparison looks for similar sentences in a patent sentence database. The determination of patentability is based on multiplying the reciprocal of the edit distance with the length index of the invention sentence and the content rate of the keyword.
11. Method for Quantifying Value Gap in Patent Portfolio Strategy Through Comparative Focus Area Ranking Analysis
International Business Machines Corporation, 2020
Identifying a value gap in a patent portfolio strategy of an organization to measure the misalignment between the organization's patent strategy and the universal market focus and quantify the business impact. The method involves comparing the organization's internal ranking of focus areas with a universal ranking based on factors like market size, potential, and trends. The difference between the rankings represents the value gap score, indicating the penalty for misaligned strategy.
12. Patent Evaluation Method Using Structural Equation Modeling with Expert-Derived Factor Analysis
KOREA INVENTION PROMOTION ASSOCIATION, 2019
Leveraging structural equation modeling to evaluate the quality and value of patents. The method involves generating an evaluation model using statistical analysis to determine the factors and weights that impact patent quality. The model is built by surveying experts to rate the importance of various factors. It then uses structural equation modeling to analyze the relationships between these factors and build an evaluation model. This model can be used to evaluate patents by inputting their data.
13. Automated System for Harvesting and Ranking Patent References with Visual Relevance Indication
Patterson Thuente Pedersen, P.A., 2018
Automating the harvesting and ranking of patent references to improve patent examination and analysis. Automated reference searching and analysis system that provides a tool to collect prior art references based on automatically harvested and pruned research threads. The system also ranks the harvested references for relevance to a claim set and presents the ranking visually.
14. Apparatus and Method for Calculating Post-Obsolescence Costs from Patent History Data
Ichiro Kudo, 2018
An apparatus and method for evaluating patent power using patent history data. The invention extracts legal procedure data from patent histories and calculates a post-obsolescence cost based on the procedures performed by third parties like requests for inspection or invalidation trials. The extracted procedures are matched to costs in a table. Post-obsolescence costs are calculated based on the filing date, procedure dates, and obsolescence functions for the technical field. Totaling the costs provides an evaluation of the patent's power.
15. Machine Learning-Based Patentability Search System with Prior Art Identification and Examiner Prediction
AT&T INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY I, L.P., 2018
System for performing patentability searches and analysis using machine learning and pre-filing analysis to improve patent quality and success rates for inventors. The system allows users to submit concept descriptions, claim terms, or draft patent applications for analysis. It conducts searches of patent and non-patent literature databases, identifies relevant prior art, and provides results to the user. The system also identifies the likely patent examiner and art unit for the application and considers frequently cited references.
16. Apparatus and Method for Calculating Cooperative Similarity Score Between Patent Documents
KOREA INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY INFORMATION, 2018
An apparatus and method for forecasting patent disputes. It extracts keywords from the claims and background of two patent documents and calculates similarity between them using those keywords. The claim and background similarities are combined to give a cooperative similarity score, which represents the probability that the documents are infringing on each other.
Request the PDF report with complete details of all 16 patents for offline reading.
Showcasing a range of methodologies, the innovations offered include blockchain-based risk assessment platforms and AI-driven legal language analysis. A clearer image of a patent's value is given by these systems, which attempt to objectively evaluate elements including novelty, legal defensibility, and market potential.